US

SCOTUS Overturns Century Old NY Law That Restricted The Right to Bear Arms

It wasn’t the decision the entire country was waiting on, but the SCOTUS issued another controversial ruling this week, regarding a New York law that restricted the right to carry a handgun. Second Amendment supporters should like the decision.

In another 6-3 decision, the Supreme Court overturned a century-old New York law that required New Yorkers to be able to show “proper cause” to carry a handgun. The New York law stated that it is a “crime to possess a firearm without a license, whether inside or outside the home. An individual who wants to carry a firearm outside his home may obtain an unrestricted license to ‘have and carry’ a concealed ‘pistol or revolver’ if he can prove that ‘proper cause exists’ for doing so. N. Y. Penal Law Ann. §400.00(2)(f ). An applicant satisfies the ‘proper cause’ requirement only if he can ‘demonstrate a special need for self-protection distinguishable from that of the general community.’”

Associate Justice Clarence Thomas wrote the majority opinion for the Court. Thomas wrote “New York’s proper-cause requirement violates the Fourteenth Amendment in that it prevents law-abiding citizens with ordinary self-defense needs from exercising their right to keep and bear arms.” 

This Twitter user put it quite well: “My proper cause is the Second Amendment New York. Also the Fourteenth Amendment.”

New York’s Governor, a Democrat, spoke about her displeasure with the Supreme Court ruling. She said, in part, “… Shocking. Absolutely shocking that they have taken away our right to have reasonable restrictions. We can have restrictions on speech. You can’t yell ‘fire’ in a crowded theater. But somehow there’s no restrictions allowed on the Second Amendment. This is New York, we don’t back down. We fight back.”

Actor James Woods had something to say about that:

In their dissent, the three liberal justices wrote that “45,222 Americans were killed by firearms in 2020 and that gun violence has surpassed motor vehicle crashes as the leading cause of death among children and adolescents.” Justice Breyer, who penned the dissenting opinion, added that “[m[any states have tried to address some of the dangers of gun violence just described by passing laws that limit, in various ways, who may purchase, carry, or use firearms of different kinds. The court today severely burdens states’ efforts to do so.”

New York’s Governor, Kathy Hochul, says she will continue to fight after the Supreme Court struck down the law. She even said, “I’m prepared to go back to muskets.” Likely, this battle is long from over, especially given what is currently being legislated in the U.S. Congress regarding gun violence. What do you think of this decision by the SCOTUS?

Stacey Warner

View Comments

  • "proper cause" is JUST AN OPINION by a single or group of people. This is called a DICTATORSHIP! Our American Constitution ACKNOWLEDGES the RIGHT of American Citizens to DEFEND ourselves and others! Maryland MUST change the DICTATORIAL REGULATIONS it is now IMPOSING Against Legal Law Abiding American Citizens.

  • When the Government tries to restrict your ownership of a gun, then you know why the second amendment was written.

Recent Posts

Kevin Costner Breaks Silence: ‘Crushing’ Divorce and Moving Forward

"Kevin Costner Breaks Silence: 'Crushing' Divorce and Moving Forward" "Hollywood Icon Kevin Costner Opens Up…

4 months ago

Walgreens Considers Major Store Closures Amid Retail Challenges

Walgreens Boots Alliance CEO Tim Wentworth announced potential closures of a "meaningful percent" of the…

4 months ago

Dave Grohl’s Concert Pause: Foo Fighters Frontman Puts Safety First

Dave Grohl, Foo Fighters frontman, halted a concert in Birmingham to address a crowd disturbance.…

4 months ago

Panthers’ Paradise: Florida’s Stanley Cup Celebration Reaches Legendary Status

The Florida Panthers have etched their names in NHL history not just for their on-ice…

4 months ago

Chanel West Coast’s Double Life: New Reality Show Reveals Star’s Struggles

By day, I'm mom. By night, I'm an artist," Chanel West Coast says in the…

4 months ago

Media Matters Funnels Six-Figure Sum to Board Member’s Firm

Media Matters for America, a nonprofit focused on correcting "conservative misinformation," paid $105,000 in 2022…

4 months ago