Nearly half of the working-class voters who delivered Donald Trump the White House in 2024 did not show up for the 2026 midterm elections, according to pollster James Johnson, co-founder of J.L. Partners.
Johnson made the disclosure during an appearance on Breitbart News Saturday, telling host Matthew Boyle that the turnout gap was the decisive factor in a brutal night for Republicans.
"The fact that turnout had such a big impact does give some hope for Republicans, because midterms are a very different type of electorate. A different voter comes out, and here it was the Trump voter that really didn't come out, and it was particularly that sort of… going back to 2016, the base that delivered Trump that win more than 10, well 10 years ago — non-graduates, those without college degrees, those non-graduates who voted Trump in 2024, 46 percent of them, nearly half didn't turn out in the midterm elections this year."
Breitbart News Saturday airs on SiriusXM Patriot 125 from 10:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. Eastern.
The numbers Johnson cited line up with the battering Republicans took at the ballot box. According to an analysis by The Guardian, Democrats flipped more than 45 House seats, nine Senate seats and six governors' offices. The Guardian also reported that half of the Senate candidates Trump endorsed lost — up from 35% in 2024, according to Ballotpedia figures cited by the outlet — and that most of the governors he backed were defeated.
Trump's endorsement record took hits even in reliably conservative territory. The Guardian reported that in Texas, Trump refused to endorse incumbent Sen. John Cornyn and instead backed Attorney General Ken Paxton in the primary; in South Carolina, he hand-picked Darline Graham, the sister of the late Sen. Lindsey Graham, despite her having no formal political experience. The outlet characterized the results as voters' widespread disapproval of the president.
Trump has brushed that framing aside, claiming Republicans would have won had his name been on the ballot, according to The Guardian.
Johnson's read is different: the problem was not that Trump voters switched sides. It was that they stayed home. Midterm electorates are older, wealthier and more highly educated than presidential-year electorates, and the voters who powered Trump's 2024 coalition — non-college-educated Americans — were the least likely to turn out this cycle.
The fallout is still being felt on Capitol Hill. House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., is pleading with Republicans to return to Washington after the Thanksgiving break, citing a slate of legislative priorities that must be addressed, KSL.com reported. That the Speaker has to publicly round up his own conference eight hours after the story broke tells you how rattled the GOP is.
For rank-and-file conservatives, the message is uncomfortable but impossible to ignore: the movement's most loyal voters do not automatically show up for anyone not named Trump. Candidates who want to ride his coalition have to earn those voters themselves — and so far, they have not.
Our Take
Let's be blunt about what Johnson is saying. The GOP did not lose the midterms because Democrats out-organized them. It lost because the voters who put Trump in office in 2024 — the non-graduates, the working-class patriots who lined up for hours at rallies — sat this one out. Forty-six percent. Nearly half.
That is not a repudiation of Trump's agenda. It is a turnout problem, and it is fixable. The Republican Party has spent years treating Trump's coalition as a permanent possession rather than a coalition that has to be re-earned every election. It does not work that way. The voters who showed up in 2024 did so because Trump asked them to and because he made them believe their concerns were heard. Candidates who inherit his endorsement but none of his connection to those voters get the worst of both worlds.
Democrats are already crowing about a mandate they did not earn. They flipped seats not because voters embraced their radical agenda, but because nearly half of Trump's base stayed on the couch. The Left knows this.
The 2028 election is already being framed as a comeback story — but only if the GOP learns the lesson now: the base is not a given. It is a loan. The question is whether Republicans will spend the next two years earning the trust of the voters who stayed home — or whether they will keep blaming everyone else while the base stays home again.


