Politics

BOMBSHELL: Alaska Dem Mary Peltola Unseats Dan Sullivan as 'Decoy Dan' Ballot Scheme Hands Dems 56-Seat Senate Majority

Gary FranchiNovember 17, 2026 ET218 views
Alaska Senate race results and ballot-counting rules face scrutiny.
Alaska Senate race results and ballot-counting rules face scrutiny. | Next News Editorial Illustration
Advertisement

Democrats have flipped their ninth Republican-held Senate seat of the 2026 midterms, with former Democratic Rep. Mary Peltola defeating two-term Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan in Alaska — a state President Donald Trump carried by roughly 13 points in 2024 — according to projections reported by Fox News and POLITICO.

The result hands Democrats a 56-44 Senate majority and makes Peltola the first Alaska Native to serve in the Senate, as well as the first Democrat to represent the state in the chamber since 2015, per The New York Times. POLITICO noted it is the first time in 18 years a Democrat has won a Senate race in Alaska.

The contest was shadowed by a controversy that broke just days before Election Day. The New York Times reported that Peltola campaign aides, attorneys and national Democratic operatives had taken part in a secret effort to recruit a candidate sharing the Republican incumbent's name — an operation internally dubbed the "ballot composition project," according to text messages and interviews reviewed by the Times. The reporting described discussions involving the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee and talk of establishing a new right-wing political party, all aimed at recruiting candidates who could siphon votes from Sullivan.

Peltola's campaign denied involvement with either Sullivan campaign, and the DSCC also rejected allegations of participation. Republican Gov. Michael Dunleavy ordered an investigation into whether the alleged recruitment effort violated Alaska law. The status of that probe was not publicly detailed as of Tuesday.

Fox News reported the projection on X, posting: "BREAKING: Democrat Mary Peltola is projected to win the Alaska Senate race, making history as the state's first Alaska Native senator. She defeats incumbent Republican Dan Sullivan after a heated campaign overshadowed by the 'Decoy Dan' ballot scandal."

Social media posts tracking the race circulated widely in the final stretch. An Instagram post indexed under the caption "Mary Peltola leads Dan Sullivan 60% to 40% in Alaska" showed campaign-related content from the contest; a separate Instagram post captioned "Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Mary Peltola is headed ..." documented the candidate on the trail. Neither post constitutes official results.

The Cook Political Report had rated the race a toss-up, reflecting an unusually competitive environment in a state that has generally favored Republicans in federal elections. Republicans were defending a seat in territory Trump won comfortably two years earlier, and Democrats eyed what the Times described as a rare opportunity to make inroads in traditionally Republican territory.

Peltola, a former state lawmaker, made history in 2022 as the first Alaska Native elected to Congress, winning a special election to succeed the late Republican Rep. Don Young. She defeated former Republican Gov. Sarah Palin in that contest and won a full term later that year before losing her 2024 reelection bid to Republican Nick Begich III — setting up her Senate run.

Sullivan, a Marine Corps veteran and former Alaska attorney general, first won his Senate seat in 2014 by defeating Democratic incumbent Mark Begich. Newsweek reported one day before the projection that Sullivan's campaign had broken its silence in the uncalled race with a promise for the week — a statement that arrived as the decoy-candidate story consumed the final days of the contest.

The ninth GOP seat lost puts Democrats at 56 in the chamber. For Alaska voters, the immediate question is what the Dunleavy investigation finds and whether the recruitment effort described by the Times is referred for prosecution. For Republicans nationally, nine flips in a single cycle is the arithmetic of a wave, and the Senate map that Trump's second term must govern through now belongs to the opposition.

Our Take

Let's be clear about what just happened in Alaska. A state Trump won by thirteen points sent a Democrat to the Senate — and it did not happen in a vacuum. According to the Times' own reporting, campaign aides, attorneys and national operatives were involved in a scheme to put a second "Dan Sullivan" on the ballot to bleed votes from the real one. Peltola's campaign and the DSCC deny it. Fine. Then they should have no objection to Governor Dunleavy's investigation running to completion and the findings being made public.

Nine seats. That is the number patriots need to sit with. The same national machine that spent years telling you the border was fine and the economy was strong just ran the table on Senate races, and in Alaska it allegedly did so with a ballot trick straight out of a banana republic playbook. The legacy media will call this a repudiation. We call it a warning: when the rules themselves become the weapon, no red state is safe, and the only answer is election integrity with teeth — real investigations, real prosecutions, real consequences.

Alaskans deserve to know who funded the "ballot composition project," who recruited the decoy, and who signed off. Until Dunleavy's probe delivers answers, every claim that this was a clean win should be treated with the skepticism it has earned. The question now is simple, folks: will anyone be held accountable, or does the machine get away with it again?

Advertisement
Advertisement
Gary Franchi
Gary Franchi

Chief White House Correspondent at Next News Network. Executive Producer and Lead Anchor.

Share this article:

Comments (10)

Leave a Comment

R
RedStateRebelVerifiedNov 18, 10:48 AM ET
This is exactly why ranked-choice voting needs to go. Alaska's system is a disaster and this proves it.
G
GraniteStateGrannyVerifiedNov 18, 7:48 PM ET
I volunteered as a poll watcher for years back in New Hampshire and I've seen how sloppy these mail-in operations can get. If there's fraud in Alaska, we need a full audit, not just a headline.
F
FreedomFanaticVerifiedNov 19, 4:48 AM ET
FINALLY someone is reporting on this! Share it everywhere before they bury it!
P
PatriotSueAKVerifiedNov 19, 8:48 AM ET
I live in Anchorage and voted for Sullivan twice — nobody I know has ever heard of a 'Decoy Dan' ballot scheme. This sounds completely fabricated. Can anyone actually link to a primary source here?
L
LibertyRider1776VerifiedNov 19, 2:48 PM ET
I've been looking all morning and can't find any official record of this scheme. Maybe check the state Division of Elections site before we run with it.
M
MAGA_Mike_907VerifiedNov 19, 4:48 PM ET
The article says it's a bombshell, sources are probably coming. But yeah I'd like to see the actual ballots.
C
ConstitutionalCarlVerifiedNov 19, 8:48 AM ET
Wait — Peltola already held the House seat from the special election. The Senate race is a different thing entirely. Is this article mixing up the two races or am I missing something?
P
PatriotSueAKVerifiedNov 19, 12:48 PM ET
You're not missing anything. Peltola is a House member. Sullivan is a Senator. This headline doesn't make sense.
L
LibertyLady77VerifiedNov 19, 4:48 PM ET
My husband was stationed at Fort Wainwright for six years and we still have friends in Fairbanks. Everyone there is furious about how the last few elections went down. A 56-seat majority would be catastrophic — we need investigations now.
C
ConstitutionalCarlVerifiedNov 19, 10:48 PM ET
Furious about what specifically? Genuinely asking — I want to understand what folks on the ground are seeing.