The White House on Tuesday slammed Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed's "Trumpcare for All" pitch, warning that the Michigan Democrat's Medicare for All proposal would threaten the health coverage millions of Americans already rely on.
The rebuke came after El-Sayed, who won Michigan's Senate race on Nov. 3, made a public appeal to President Donald Trump to back a universal, taxpayer-funded health plan — complete with a mock gold "TrumpCare" card bearing the president's signature. The card, which El-Sayed posted to X last Thursday, promises $0 premiums and copays for every American and lists coverage for hospital care, prescription drugs, and dental, vision and hearing starting in 2027.
"Donald, this is on the table," El-Sayed wrote in the post. "Guarantee healthcare for every American, from cradle to grave."
The design mimics the administration's Trump Gold Card visa program for wealthy foreigners, which costs at least $1 million. El-Sayed, an epidemiologist and former Detroit health director, told CNN on Nov. 10 that Trump could "finally meet the unmet promise in America to guarantee everybody healthcare." He made the same pitch to NPR last Thursday, saying Congress needs to pass Medicare for All. "Put his name on it," he said.
White House Warns of Coverage Losses
The White House pushed back hard, warning that El-Sayed's plan would upend the private insurance market and cost taxpayers trillions. The administration pointed to its own health care framework, "The Great Healthcare Plan," released in January, which it says would send subsidies directly to consumers rather than expanding government-run coverage.
The dispute pits El-Sayed's call for a universal, taxpayer-funded health plan against White House warnings about coverage losses and higher federal spending, according to reporting from Межа.
The White House's criticism lands as El-Sayed's past comments about the president resurface. During the 2024 campaign, El-Sayed called Trump an "unserious fool" — a remark the White House now cites as evidence that his sudden praise of the president is less about policy than about publicity.
El-Sayed also made appeals to Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to work across the aisle on health policy, according to reporting from Bloomberg Government. It is not yet known whether the administration has responded to those appeals.
The freshman senator's pitch has drawn scrutiny from conservatives who note that Medicare for All has been estimated to cost tens of trillions of dollars and would eliminate the private insurance plans that most Americans get through their employers. El-Sayed made the plan the centerpiece of his campaign, defeating Republican former Rep. Mike Rogers to succeed retiring Democratic Sen. Gary Peters.
Our Take
Let's call this what it is: a slick marketing stunt from a newly elected senator who spent the campaign trashing Donald Trump and is now trying to piggyback on the president's popularity with a gold card and a 1-800 number. El-Sayed called Trump an "unserious fool" — and now wants us to believe he's the guy to hand the president a pen and a universal health care bill? Please.
But the policy behind the gimmick is deadly serious — and deadly for American health care. Medicare for All isn't a promise of free stuff; it's a promise to rip away the private coverage that millions of families depend on, replace it with a government-run monopoly, and stick future generations with a bill so large it makes the national debt look like pocket change. The White House is right to warn that El-Sayed's plan would threaten existing coverage. That's not a talking point — it's the plan's operating principle.
If El-Sayed really wants to work across the aisle, he can start by dropping the recycled socialist playbook and getting behind the president's market-based reforms. Americans deserve real solutions — not a gold card with a phone number that leads nowhere.


