Fox News Radio host Brian Kilmeade told listeners Tuesday that Vice President JD Vance "never should’ve been Vice President," accusing him of building a strawman argument about President Donald Trump’s war in Iran, Breitbart reported.
On "The Brian Kilmeade Show," the host played a clip of Vance’s exchange with Fox News host Laura Ingraham, in which the vice president said the conflict was not "a forever war" and that Trump would eventually bring it to a close. "There are going to be people who demand more, who want the war to go on indefinitely," Vance said in the clip.
Kilmeade was not buying it. "I had to play this. It is so aggravating. There is not one person that I have ever met that wants an endless war, who will say the president’s got to keep fighting no matter what," he said, according to Mediaite’s account of the broadcast. "I’m talking about the vice president of the United States. Never should have been vice president."
The host then turned to Vance’s post-midterm remarks. After Republicans were trounced in the midterms, the vice president said that "any honest conversation" about the defeat had to start with the Iran war. Kilmeade mocked the framing: "Really? So you’re telling me how I have to argue something? And my beliefs, if I don’t argue the way you want me to, it’s not worth your time?" he asked.
The segment landed one day after Ingraham pressed Vance on the administration’s handling of last week’s air traffic control disruption, according to HuffPost. That interview produced the clip Kilmeade played Tuesday — and Kilmeade took the criticism a step further than his colleague.
The war in Iran has become the fault line inside the MAGA coalition. Vance, who is weighing a 2028 presidential run, made headlines the day after the midterms by blaming the GOP wipeout on the war and making clear he did not agree with continuing it, the Daily Mail noted. The vice president has insisted there is "no daylight" between him and Trump on the matter and that the president will not let the conflict become a "forever war."
Conservative commentator Mark Levin said on X that Politico is preparing a story arguing that criticism from Kilmeade, Marc Thiessen and Levin himself is "broadening and strengthening" Vance’s support. Levin, a former Reagan administration official, was unimpressed. "Now, folks, I’ve been around a few years. I’ve seen presidents and vice presidents come and go. I’ve seen politicians come and go," he wrote.
It is not yet known whether the White House or the vice president’s office responded to Kilmeade’s remarks. Vance has not publicly addressed the segment.
The episode puts a spotlight on a vice president openly distancing himself from a war his own administration is prosecuting — while the president’s allies on Fox News and in conservative media increasingly say so out loud. For Republican voters who backed Trump’s America First promise to end foreign entanglements, the fight is not abstract: it is a question of whether the ticket they elected in 2024 still speaks with one voice on the war.
Our Take
Kilmeade said what a lot of patriots have been thinking. Vance’s answer to Ingraham was a textbook strawman — he set up an imaginary army of "endless war" cheerleaders and then knocked them down, all while the actual question was whether he supports the war his own administration is running. The American people who voted for Trump in 2024 did not sign up for a vice president who treats the anti-war wing of the party as the enemy and the skeptics as people who just don’t argue the right way.
And Levin’s post exposes the game. The same establishment that spent years calling Trump supporters a threat now wants to tell us that criticism from Kilmeade, Thiessen and Levin is somehow good for Vance. It isn’t. It’s a tell — the GOP donor class is already auditioning its 2028 favorite, and the vice president is playing along.
The question for every Republican is simple: if you were elected to end forever wars, why is your vice president lecturing the base about how to talk about one? The White House should answer that plainly — and Vance should answer it without a strawman in front of him.


