House Democrats formally nominated Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., to be the next speaker of the House on Wednesday, handing him a 251-11 victory in a closed-door, secret-ballot vote — but not before a small bloc of incoming progressives made clear they are not on board with the direction he is taking the party.
The vote, first reported by Fox News Digital and confirmed by CBS News and NBC News, advances Jeffries as the party's nominee to lead what Democrats expect will be a majority of more than 250 seats in the 120th Congress. The full House will elect the speaker in January, and with that margin, Jeffries' path to 218 votes is all but secured. He would become the first Black speaker in U.S. history.
"It was a blowout number," Rep. Bennie Thompson, D-Miss., told Fox News Digital after the vote. The committee room reportedly erupted in cheering and applause once the tally was announced.
The Eleven Who Said No
Jeffries ran unopposed, but that did not stop eleven Democrats from voting against him — seven of them newly elected members who issued a joint statement explaining their opposition. Reps.-elect Darializa Avila Chevalier, D-N.Y., Adam Hamawy, D-N.J., Frederick Haynes, D-Texas, Melat Kiros, D-Colo., Donavan McKinney, D-Mich., Chris Rabb, D-Pa., and Claire Valdez, D-N.Y., said they wanted policy commitments before they would back him.
"Whether on Medicare for All, stopping ICE terror, getting money out of politics, or ending the genocide in Gaza, our constituents sent us to Congress with a mandate on these issues," the seven said in their statement. "While we have seen meaningful progress, there is still work to be done to ensure that the direction our party takes this coming Congress reflects what our constituents are demanding of leadership."
Rep.-elect Don Leonard, D-Ohio, who flipped a district Trump carried in 2024, told local media before the vote that he would be "shopping for a new leader" if Jeffries did not commit to changing his position on Israel. Rep.-elect Hamawy declined to comment to Fox News Digital when asked how he voted — then was confirmed to have voted against Jeffries. Rep. Jonathan Jackson, D-Ill., told Fox News Digital that the members who opposed Jeffries were being "unfair," arguing they had never seen him in action.
The pushback was not confined to Capitol Hill. Instagram posts circulating this week showed Jeffries nominating coverage and progressive pressure on his leadership — a sign the rebellion had an online audience even as it collapsed in the room. Reporting from Fox News Digital indicated Democratic congressional offices had been inundated with calls from frustrated voters urging lawmakers to pick someone else. In the end, no alternative candidate emerged.
A Caucus That Voted — and a Party That Grumbled
Jeffries allies had pushed for a vote by acclamation, which would have avoided a public tally. According to NBC News, Jeffries instead asked for a recorded vote so members could voice support or opposition, comparing it to the 2018 caucus vote that returned Nancy Pelosi to the speaker's office amid calls for generational change.
The caucus also elevated Rep. Katherine Clark, D-Mass., as majority leader — the first woman to hold that position, per CBS News. Jeffries was nominated by a group including Rep. Teresa Leger Fernández, D-N.M., Rep. Derek Tran, D-Calif., Rep. Mark Pocan, D-Wis., Rep.-elect Rebecca Bennett, D-N.J., and former Majority Whip Jim Clyburn, D-S.C.
"This is a very surreal moment for me," Clyburn told reporters before the vote. "The results of today's election speak for themselves," Jeffries said at a news conference afterward.
What the eleven dissenting votes actually change is limited. With a majority above 250 seats, eleven defections cannot block Jeffries on the floor in January. But the statement from the seven incoming members names the fights that will define the next Congress inside the Democratic caucus: Israel, ICE, campaign finance and health care. Those are the pressure points their constituents will be watching — and the ones Republican campaigns will be quoting back at them for the next two years.
Our Take
Here is what the 251-11 score actually tells you: Hakeem Jeffries is speaker-in-waiting, and the progressive wing of his party knows it can't stop him — so it is already building a public record of dissent. Seven brand-new members just voted against their own leader on Day One and put their names on a statement calling ICE a "terror" and accusing Israel of "genocide." Those aren't moderates. Those are the incoming face of the Democratic caucus, and they are telling voters exactly what they intend to push for.
Patriots should file this away. The same party that spent years claiming to be the adults in the room just elevated a freshman class that wants to defund immigration enforcement and turn on our closest ally. Jeffries may have won Wednesday — but he won with a caucus that is already leaking. Republicans should welcome that fight, and voters should remember who the eleven were. The January speaker vote is a formality. The real vote is in November 2028, and the Democratic Party just showed its hand.


