Politics

DOJ DROPS 'DECOY DAN' LAWSUIT: Peltola Wins Alaska Senate Seat as Trump Administration Admits Case Is Moot

Gary FranchiNovember 20, 2026 ET252 views
Alaska Senate ballot dispute ends as courts weigh election certification.
Alaska Senate ballot dispute ends as courts weigh election certification. | Next News Editorial Illustration
Advertisement

WASHINGTON — The Department of Justice on Thursday asked a federal appeals court to dismiss its lawsuit challenging the certification of Alaska's Senate race, after Democrat Mary Peltola was declared the winner over two-term Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan earlier this week.

The filing with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals came two days after the Associated Press called the race for Peltola, who won an outright majority of first-choice votes. The DOJ's lawsuit, filed in October, had sought to block certification of the election unless Sen. Sullivan emerged victorious — a scenario that never materialized.

In its motion Thursday, the Justice Department asked the appeals court to declare the case moot, citing Peltola's victory. "The United States brought this lawsuit to ensure that the State and its officers fulfill Alaska's obligation to protect the integrity of its election," Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward wrote in the filing, according to NBC News. He added that the government "therefore reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means" of examining whether votes cast for Dan J. Sullivan were intended for the incumbent.

The lawsuit centered on the presence of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. — a retired Petersburg schoolteacher who shared the senator's name on the ballot — whom President Trump repeatedly described as a "decoy" designed to "defraud" voters. The administration's suit turned on a single scenario: Sullivan losing, but by fewer votes than his namesake received. In that event, the DOJ wanted certification blocked until investigators could determine whether voters who chose Sullivan Jr. had meant to choose the senator.

U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case on November 1, two days before the election, ruling that the federal government lacked standing and that setting ballots aside would violate the secret ballot. The department appealed the same day. The appeal was rendered pointless by Peltola's win.

"I'm the one that said 'do it,'" Trump later said of the lawsuit, according to Newsweek.

Attorney General Todd Blanche has said a federal criminal investigation into the candidacy of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. is continuing. Sullivan has not posted publicly since the race was called.

Alaska's Department of Law, representing the state, had opposed the federal suit. The case drew scrutiny from legal observers who questioned how the government could examine voter intent without breaching the secret ballot — a question the DOJ never answered, according to its own filing.

Peltola, a former congresswoman, defeated Sullivan in a state Trump carried comfortably in 2024. Her victory marks a rare Democratic pickup in a Senate cycle that otherwise favored Republicans, though the GOP still holds the chamber.

Democrats celebrated the outcome.

Republicans, meanwhile, were left to regroup. The National Republican Senatorial Committee did not respond to a request for comment by publication time.

The dismissal, while a procedural move, carries political weight. It closes a chapter in which the Trump administration used the full force of the Justice Department to intervene in a state election — an extraordinary step that drew bipartisan criticism from election officials in Alaska, who said the suit threatened to undermine confidence in the state's certified results.

It is not yet known whether the criminal investigation into Sullivan Jr.'s candidacy will produce charges. The DOJ declined to comment beyond its court filing.

Our Take

Here's what the mainstream media won't tell you: the Trump administration was right to fight for election integrity in Alaska. When a candidate with the exact same name as a sitting senator appears on the ballot, voters deserve to know whether that was a deliberate scheme to siphon votes. The DOJ's lawsuit wasn't about overturning an election — it was about ensuring that every vote counted was the vote the voter intended to cast.

But the courts — and ultimately the voters — had the final say. Judge Gleason's ruling that the government lacked standing was a predictable setback from a judiciary that too often bends over backwards to protect the status quo. And Peltola's outright majority win made the legal fight academic. The DOJ did the right thing by dropping a case that no longer had a purpose.

Now the question turns to accountability. If Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. was put on that ballot as a decoy — and the criminal investigation suggests the feds believe there's something there — then the people behind that scheme must be held to account. The American people deserve nothing less.

As for Senate Republicans, this loss should be a wake-up call. Alaska is Trump country. If the GOP can't hold a Senate seat there, what does that say about the party's operation? The midterms are behind us, but 2028 is already on the horizon. The America First movement needs leaders who can win — and who won't let a ballot stunt steal a seat.

Stay tuned. The criminal probe into the "decoy Dan" operation is still ongoing, and if the DOJ finds evidence of deliberate election fraud, we'll be the first to report it.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Gary Franchi
Gary Franchi

Chief White House Correspondent at Next News Network. Executive Producer and Lead Anchor.

Share this article:

Comments (8)

Leave a Comment

L
LibertyLass907VerifiedNov 20, 7:29 PM ET
About time the DOJ dropped this nonsense. The whole 'Decoy Dan' thing smelled like a political hit job from day one, and now they're admitting it's moot because Peltola already won. Taxpayer money well wasted, as usual.
M
MatanuskaMikeVerifiedNov 20, 7:29 PM ET
Exactly. They knew it was moot weeks ago but dragged it out for the headlines.
P
PatriotInTheValleyVerifiedNov 21, 1:29 AM ET
Moot is just lawyer-speak for 'we lost and we know it.'
F
FrostyPatriotVerifiedNov 20, 8:29 PM ET
So does this mean the Senate seat is settled for good, or can they still try to challenge the certification later? Genuinely asking because the legal timeline on these things confuses me.
S
SarahFromWasillaVerifiedNov 20, 11:29 PM ET
LOL. Decoy Dan. The nickname alone should've been a clue this was theater. Glad it's over and Alaska can move on.
N
NorthSlopeNateVerifiedNov 21, 3:29 AM ET
The nickname was the best part of the whole saga honestly.
B
BigSkyBruinVerifiedNov 21, 12:29 AM ET
The establishment keeps underestimating how tired regular folks are of these legally dubious stunts. This is a win for rule of law, plain and simple. Hopefully the next administration thinks twice before filing something this flimsy.
K
KenaiConservativeVerifiedNov 21, 9:29 PM ET
I've followed Alaska politics for thirty years and I've never seen anything like this Decoy Dan circus. The fact that the Trump DOJ is quietly walking away tells you everything about how weak the case was. Good riddance.