Politics

VICTORY BY A COIN FLIP: Deadlocked Florida Race Settles 3,162-3,162 Tie in 20 Seconds

Gary FranchiNovember 20, 2026 ET90 views
A single coin toss settles a deadlocked municipal election race.
A single coin toss settles a deadlocked municipal election race. | Next News Editorial Illustration
Advertisement

Forget hanging chads. In Atlantic Beach, Florida, they flipped a coin.

Jennifer Lagner will represent City Commission Seat 4 after a race tied at exactly 3,162 votes survived both a machine recount and a manual recount without producing a winner. With the deadlock intact, Duval County Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland oversaw the tiebreaker on the sidewalk outside his office, in front of roughly a dozen spectators — a best-of-three coin toss that took about twenty seconds, according to the New York Post's account of the event.

Lisa Herrold called the first flip. She chose heads. The coin came up tails. Lagner called the second flip, correctly picked heads, and the seat was hers, 2-0, before a third toss was needed.

The procedure wasn't improvised. Under Florida law, a tied election can be resolved "by lot" — a game of chance — which makes the coin toss a legally recognized method of determining a winner, according to the New York Post. In Duval County, it's a method election officials have used before: in 2014, a tied Neptune Beach City Council race between Richard Arthur and Rory Diamond was settled when the two candidates drew numbered ping pong balls, with the higher number winning. Arthur won.

Herrold took the outcome better than most politicians take a loss. "Jen and I have been a part of this community for years... It was meant to be... We're going to look back at this and realize how unbelievable this was," she told a local outlet, as reported by WKXB.

The result closes a contest that went to the wire in every sense. Two candidates, two full recounts, 6,324 votes cast between them, and not a single vote separating them. Lagner, Herrold, and the Duval County Supervisor of Elections did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital's request for further comment, according to that outlet's reporting.

Florida voters watching from outside Atlantic Beach may be wondering what the margin was in their own races. The answer, in this one: nothing. Not one vote. And the tiebreaker wasn't a runoff, wasn't a special election, wasn't a panel of judges — it was a quarter in the air outside an elections office, and a woman who guessed right calling heads.

Our Take

Here's the uncomfortable question nobody in the legacy media wants to ask: how does a race for a city commission seat end in a perfect tie after two recounts? Americans are told every cycle that our elections are the most secure, the most accurate, the most trustworthy in the world. Then a race gets counted, and recounted, and comes out exactly even. That doesn't show accuracy. That doesn't inspire confidence. That's a coin flip standing in for the will of 3,162 people on each side.

Floridians deserve a Legislature that fixes this before the next tie comes along — a runoff election, held two weeks later, with voters actually deciding the outcome. If two candidates can't be separated by a single vote out of thousands, the answer isn't a game of chance on a sidewalk. The answer is sending it back to the people. It's not hard. It's not expensive. It's not complicated. It's what a republic is supposed to do.

And spare a thought for Lisa Herrold. She came within one coin flip of public office — and the coin came up tails. That's not a judgment on her campaign, her record, or her service to that community. That's randomness. Voters in Atlantic Beach should be asking whether randomness is really how they want their representation chosen. We think they shouldn't have to.

Want to make sure your vote never comes down to heads or tails? Show up. Check your registration. Vote in the races nobody covers. The lower the turnout, the more likely a race comes down to one vote — or one flip.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Gary Franchi
Gary Franchi

Chief White House Correspondent at Next News Network. Executive Producer and Lead Anchor.

Share this article:

Comments (7)

Leave a Comment

C
ConstitutionalKenVerifiedNov 20, 4:08 PM ET
Does anyone know if Florida law actually requires a coin flip in this situation, or could they have held a runoff instead? Seems like there ought to be a better remedy than chance.
S
SunshineStateSteveVerifiedNov 21, 3:08 AM ET
State statute allows lots for ties in some races, but a special election is usually the cleaner fix.
G
GrannyMae1951VerifiedNov 21, 7:08 AM ET
I remember when our local school board race ended in a tie back in the 80s and they settled it by drawing a name out of a hat. Folks were furious then too, but at least everyone knew the rules going in.
R
RedWaveRiderVerifiedNov 21, 2:08 PM ET
3,162 to 3,162 and it comes down to heads or tails — you can't make this stuff up! Great reporting.
P
PatriotSam72VerifiedNov 22, 3:08 AM ET
A coin flip deciding an election is exactly what happens when we let bureaucrats run the process instead of demanding real accountability. Our founders would be rolling in their graves.
L
LibertyBellGalVerifiedNov 22, 4:08 AM ET
Exactly right. This is what happens when nobody bothers to fix the actual problem.
C
CommonSenseDaveVerifiedNov 22, 1:08 PM ET
Twenty seconds to undo thousands of votes. Unbelievable.