Politics

BOMBSHELL: Jeffries' 'Sixth Borough' Jerusalem Remark Resurfaces as Progressives Abandon Israel Ahead of Speaker Vote

Gary FranchiNovember 22, 2026 ET178 views
Jeffries' Jerusalem remarks return as Democratic Israel policy shifts before the speaker vote.
Jeffries' Jerusalem remarks return as Democratic Israel policy shifts before the speaker vote. | Next News Editorial Illustration
Advertisement

A six-year-old interview is back in the spotlight, and it could not have returned at a worse time for House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries. In a 2020 sit-down with the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), Jeffries described Jerusalem as New York City's "6th Borough"—a remark that is now circulating widely on social media as the progressive wing of his party escalates its break with Israel.

The clip resurfaced this week as Jeffries prepares for a January floor vote to become Speaker. He won the Democratic caucus nomination by secret ballot, with 251 members voting in his favor and just 11 against, according to Fox News Politics. But that internal margin masks a deeper divide: a growing faction of Democrats is openly hostile to AIPAC and to the political favor Israel has historically enjoyed among lawmakers.

In the 2020 interview, Jeffries recalled a conversation about his repeated trips to Israel. "Someone said to me, 'Hakeem, you're going to Israel a 5th time?'" Jeffries said, per Fox News Politics. "I said, 'listen, I'm from New York City'—and back home in New York City, we consider Jerusalem to be the 6th Borough. And so, I'm just trying to catch up with my constituents."

He went further in the same interview, describing Israel's security environment in stark terms. "I think when you're on the ground, for me it's always been clear that Israel lives in an incredibly tough neighborhood," Jeffries said. "When you think about the dangerous situation in the Sinai to the south, Hamas in Gaza, Hezbollah to the north, Syria and chaos to the east, Iraq still a mess, Iran with nuclear ambitions and a tremendously bad actor—I grew up in Brooklyn in the late 80s and early 90s, I know from tough neighborhoods that Israel lives in a tough neighborhood."

The Progressive Break

That position now puts Jeffries at odds with a rising bloc in his own caucus. According to Fox News Politics, at least eight members set to join the 120th Congress have ties to the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), a group that aims to "end all military and economic aid to Israel." That is eight votes Jeffries cannot count on when he needs a simple majority of the 435-member House to take the Speaker's gavel in January.

The blowback is already visible online. An Instagram post referenced Jeffries as "AIPAC Shakur"—a mocking nickname that pairs his name with the pro-Israel lobbying group. Another post noted that Jeffries is facing pressure from progressives. A third post referenced Jeffries saying "Israel today." The posts, which are circulating on Instagram, reflect an increasingly hostile online environment for any Democrat who maintains traditional support for the Jewish state.

The practical question is how far Jeffries will go to placate the anti-Israel faction in his party. Fox News Politics reports that he has called for changes to the U.S.-Israel security relationship—a shift from the tone he struck in 2020. Whether that is genuine conviction or a calculation to secure the Speaker's gavel is not publicly known.

What It Means for New York

Jeffries represents a Brooklyn district with a substantial Jewish population, and his "6th Borough" comment was rooted in representing those constituents. But New York politics have shifted. Progressive challengers have made Israel a litmus test in Democratic primaries, and the DSA-aligned wing of the party has made clear it will not accept the old consensus.

The speaker vote is scheduled for January. Jeffries needs 218 votes if all members are present and voting. With at least eight Democrats aligned with DSA, he can afford almost no defections—and the resurfaced clip gives his critics fresh ammunition.

Our Take

This is what happens when a party's leadership tries to be everything to everyone. Hakeem Jeffries spent years telling New York's Jewish community he was one of them—Jerusalem as the sixth borough, Israel in a tough neighborhood, all the right notes. Now he is heading toward a Speaker vote and the loudest voices in his caucus are threatening to withhold support unless he abandons that position.

The clip going viral is not an accident. It is a reminder to voters that Jeffries' past words do not match his party's present direction. Republicans should put this clip in every ad they run in New York and every district with a significant Jewish population. Let voters see what Jeffries said when he thought it was safe—and what he is willing to say now that the progressives are calling the shots.

If Jeffries folds to the DSA wing, he will have traded a core Democratic constituency for a handful of votes from a faction that has made clear it wants to end aid to Israel entirely. That is not leadership. That is capitulation. And the voters who heard "sixth borough" in 2020 are going to remember it in 2028.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Gary Franchi
Gary Franchi

Chief White House Correspondent at Next News Network. Executive Producer and Lead Anchor.

Share this article:

Comments (12)

Leave a Comment

L
LibertyBell1776VerifiedNov 23, 2:01 AM ET
This is exactly why we need to pay attention to every word these politicians say. Jeffries showed his true colors and now he's trying to pretend otherwise.
P
PatriotMom84VerifiedNov 23, 4:01 AM ET
Exactly right. They always tell us who they are if we're willing to listen.
P
ProudDeplorableVerifiedNov 23, 7:01 AM ET
BOMBSHELL indeed! This should be front page news everywhere but you won't hear a peep from the mainstream media.
S
SmallGovConservativeVerifiedNov 23, 9:01 AM ET
The 'Sixth Borough' comment is revealing because it shows how these politicians actually view their relationships with foreign nations - as political bargaining chips.
G
GodBlessAmericaTXVerifiedNov 23, 4:01 PM ET
Standing with Israel isn't complicated. It's the only democracy in the Middle East and our strongest ally there. Period.
C
ConstitutionFirstVerifiedNov 23, 4:01 PM ET
Can someone explain why the media buried this story for so long? Seems like they only bring it up when it's convenient for their narrative.
L
LibertyLadVerifiedNov 23, 6:01 PM ET
Timing is everything in politics, and the media knows exactly when to drop a story.
R
RealNewsWatcherVerifiedNov 24, 12:01 AM ET
Because they're not journalists anymore, they're activists with press credentials.
T
TexasRancher54VerifiedNov 23, 7:01 PM ET
I've voted in every election since 1980 and I've never seen the Democrat party this fractured. The progressives are eating their own alive.
F
FaithAndFreedomVerifiedNov 24, 2:01 AM ET
My grandfather fought in WWII and would be horrified to see how the Democrat party has turned its back on our allies. This isn't the party of FDR anymore, that's for sure.
H
HistoryBuff1962VerifiedNov 24, 5:01 AM ET
The party left people like your grandfather behind decades ago. They just didn't notice until recently.
L
LibertyRisingVerifiedNov 24, 5:01 AM ET
Does anyone actually believe Jeffries didn't know what he was saying? These people are calculated, not careless.