California voters narrowly rejected a ballot measure that would have imposed a one-time 5% tax on the net worth of the state's billionaires, a defeat that one California entrepreneur says saved the state from an economic catastrophe.
Proposition 40, placed on the Nov. 3 ballot by the health care workers' union SEIU-UHW, was rejected by just over 52% of voters, according to results reported by Fox Business. The measure would have applied to California residents with a net worth exceeding $1 billion as of January 1, 2026, and would have been payable over five years, according to an analysis published by The Nation. Supporters estimated it would raise around $100 billion to offset federal budget cuts to health programs.
Eric Schiffer, CEO of Patriarch and chairman of Reputation Management Consultants, had warned before the election that the measure could drive the state's wealthiest residents and businesses elsewhere. In an interview with Fox Business, he described its defeat as a major economic victory.
"This would have been a catastrophic, mammoth hit to California and all of the people within it," Schiffer told Fox Business. "And California got lucky."
Schiffer compared the proposed tax to a "giant missile" headed toward the state, arguing that voters had prevented serious economic damage and rebuffed what he described as an attempt to "maul billionaires" that could have triggered a mass exodus of wealth and jobs.
"People are smart. They saw through it," he said, asserting that voters recognized the potential economic consequences of driving wealthy entrepreneurs and their businesses out of the state.
"If you tax a billionaire, do you then tax someone worth a couple hundred million dollars, which then would cause others to leave?" Schiffer asked. "And then do you go down to a million dollars at some point?"
Before the election, Schiffer warned that the proposed tax could create a "giant sucking sound" of entrepreneurs leaving California, potentially taking jobs, investment and tax revenue with them.
According to research by economists Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman cited by The Nation, California's billionaire wealth reached around $2.3 trillion by mid-2026, roughly equal to the total income reported by every Californian in a year. The approximately 250 billionaires who would have qualified pay only about 0.2 percent of their wealth in California income tax each year, representing 2.4 percent of total California income tax revenue.
In the fallout of the proposition's defeat, The Nation reported that Meta negotiated a deal with its board to issue a new class of nonvoting stock, distributed to all shareholders in January 2027. The arrangement would allow CEO Mark Zuckerberg to sell shares and convert a portion of his wealth into cash without losing his near-supermajority voting share, and he agreed to stay in the state for at least eight years, according to the outlet. The reporting suggests that even before the vote, some of the state's wealthiest residents were making contingency plans.
California voters decided the outcome of 14 state propositions this fall, including measures to require voters to show ID, speed up environmental reviews and fund affordable housing, schools and healthcare, according to KQED. With more than 99% of all votes tallied statewide as of Friday — representing 13.4 million voters, two and a half weeks after Election Day — seven measures had earned enough support to be declared winners by the Associated Press, while another six definitely failed. One final measure was trailing and supporters conceded the race, KQED reported.
Voters approved a $10 billion bond measure to fund affordable housing and related infrastructure projects and another $1.25 billion for a home loan program for veterans, according to KQED. The funds are expected to support up to 40,000 rental units and assist 40,000 families in buying a home, according to the Legislative Analyst's Office.
They also approved a measure to shore up California's "rainy day fund," formally known as the Budget Stabilization Account, expanding the fund's maximum size from 10% of general fund tax revenue to 20%, KQED reported. In 2012, voters increased tax rates for the top 2% of earners — and extended the increase in 2016 — generating roughly $10 billion a year for the general fund.
The rejection of Proposition 40 leaves in place a tax structure that proponents of the wealth tax argue allows the state's richest residents to pay a smaller share of their wealth than other earners. Opponents argue that singling out billionaires for a one-time levy would drive capital and jobs out of the state and eventually reach further down the income scale.
It is not yet known whether state lawmakers will attempt to revive a version of the wealth tax through the legislature.
Our Take
California's voters just sent a message that the radical Left's endless appetite for other people's money has a limit. Proposition 40 was never about fairness. It was a $100 billion shakedown dressed up as health care funding, and it would have landed squarely on the backs of the entrepreneurs, innovators and job creators who built the state's economy.
Schiffer is right: California got lucky. But luck is not a governing strategy. The same progressive machine that pushed this measure will be back, because the union bosses and their allies in Sacramento never stop looking for a new pot of money to raid. The only reason they failed this time is that voters — including plenty of Democrats — saw the "giant sucking sound" coming.
Look at the Meta deal reported by The Nation. One of the wealthiest men in America had to negotiate a stock restructuring and a multi-year residency commitment just to protect himself from a tax that voters ultimately rejected. That is what a hostile business climate looks like. It is also why so many entrepreneurs have already packed up and moved to Texas, Florida and Tennessee.
California's problems are not solved. The state still has a progressive tax structure that punishes success, a cost-of-living crisis and a regulatory apparatus that treats employers like suspects. Rejecting one bad ballot measure is a start, not a victory lap.
Patriots, the lesson here is simple: when government comes for the wealthy with a "one-time" tax, it never stops there. Schiffer's question — do you then go down to a million dollars at some point? — is the question every American should ask before the next wealth tax scheme lands on a ballot. The answer is almost always yes. California voters stopped it this time. Will your state be next?


